Reviewed by Markela T. (age 8) and Jesse S. (age 7)
Our favorite part is when everyone surprised Muffy when she came in the door because she was really happy. Our favorite character is Arthur. He is a nice friend to surprise Muffy. We have had birthday parties like Muffy and Arthur did. The pictures help tell the story because they have more details.
We think you should read this book because it shows how nice it is to surprise someone on their birthday. It also shows you how to be a good friend.