Written by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor

Reviewed by Emily P. (age 9)

In this book, the main characters are Marty, Shiloh, and Judd Travers. Marty is a boy who went for a walk one day and a dog followed him. The dog belonged to a man named Judd Travers. Marty did not like Judd because he had told lies.

So one day, the dog came back and Marty kept him a secret from everyone. Marty named the dog Shiloh because the dog didn't have a name. Shiloh was good and quiet until one night when Marty heard a yelp and ran up to see Shiloh. Then the trouble started.

I think that this book is very good. I liked reading it and I think my friends liked it too. The book had good descriptions, like "his tail going like a windshield wiper".

I think this book is special because it is not like any other book I have read. It has really good details. I liked the plot because it taught the lesson that something you want is worth working for.

Even though it had no pictures, as I read this book, I could picture it in my head. As I read this book it felt real. When it had sad parts, I felt kind of sad.

I recommend this book to kids in second grade and up. I also recommend this book to people who like adventures.

Emily P. is a student in Mrs. Giammusso's 2nd/3rd Grade Class