Reviewed by Jani A. (age 9)
When they went upstairs to look at his room, Arthur crossed his fingers. His mom heard a loud crash and they ran to D.W.'s room and saw lots of toys and Arthur's room was still a mess.
I like this book because he had lots of toys and he had a garage sale. I also liked that his room was messy. My favorite part was when Francine traded her comic books with Arthur because they were special to Francine.
I recommend this book to a sad person because I think it will be fun for them to read. I think other third graders will like this book.