Reviewed by Madison L. (age 8)
My favorite part was when Samantha gets the doll, because it?s Christmas and she gave her doll to her poor friend, Nellie. It was a very special thing for her to do. I like reading all the Samantha American Girl books. She is a nice character that would be a great friend. The American Girl books are fun and you learn things from them too.
I would recommend this book to girls four to fifteen who like American Girl books and surprises.