Reviewed by Ted T. (age 11)
I think the book was great because of the details. My favorite part was when Cluny was crushed under the Joseph Bell because that explains why Cluny woke up when the Joseph Bell rang. Matthais changed when Cluny vowed to take over Redwall Abbey. This book is similar to other books in the series because it includes the defeat of an evil creature.
I recommend this book because this book has an interesting scenario. I think that people who like adventure books will like this one. I think that the best part about this book is it's plot because it can't be predicted.