Uncle Max's Secret

Written by Alma Marshak Whitney
Illustrated by John C. Wallner

Reviewed by Andrea A. (age 9)

Do you like surprises? This is about Uncle Max's secret. He plans a gift for Anna. But Anna is wondering why her uncle is acting strange. Uncle Max made her happy. Read this book and find out more about Uncle Max's secret.

I like this book because it reminds me of my mom. She gave me a special gift like Uncle max in the story. I like Uncle Max because he has a good imagination. He also kept the secret until Anna's big day. I want to have an uncle like him. He is sweet and thoughtful.

I recommend this book because it is interesting. The more you read the pages of the book, the more you want to find out Uncle Max's secret.

Andrea A. is a student in Mrs. Idos' 3rd Grade Class
2003-2004