Reviewed by Aleesha A. (age 9)
I think that this is a great book because it is exciting and interesting. My favorite charactor is Miles, because he is nice and caring. He is nice because he brought Winnie for a talk out on the lake so she wouldn't be scared. My favorite part was when Miles caught a fish, and Winnie made him throw it back. She liked being on the boat but she didn't like actually catching fish!
Other people should read this book because it is a real good story . People in fifth grade and up should read it. If third graders want to read it, they should read it together with a grown-up because there are some tough words in there.