Reviewed by Arshjot S. (age 8) and Annie K. (age 8)
I think people will like to read this book because it?s funny and sometimes it made us scared. The thing that made us scared is when Comet almost loses all of his lives and has only one left. We like this book because we felt like we were in the story. We felt like we were Comet.
We especially like how Jan Brett drew the pictures. We like the borders around the page because they are beautiful. The reason why I think the borders are beautiful is it has interesting things. The island reminds us of when we were at the beach in the summer. We loved the illustrations because it almost looked real, like the picture with the water splashing. We think its better than most other books? illustrations because they have many more details.