Reviewed by Connor H. (age 9)
I like how Josh and I have a lot in common. Josh is smart and I am smart, too. One way Josh was smart was when he used his knowledge about coal cellars to save them. Also, Josh and I are both fast. My favorite part is the ending when the case was solved. I like how in the end the mystery of finding him and bringing him back to his mom is solved. I liked trying to follow all of the clues that the kids discover. One clue I liked was that the gym where Flip worked was so loud that no one could hear Win crying. I think that the illustrations are very helpful. I didnít know why they picked up the carpet but then an illustration helped me realize that there was a trapdoor under the carpet.
I would recommend this book to kids who like mysteries. I recommend this book to boys and girls because I know boys and girls who read the A to Z mystery books. I also recommend this book to kids ages 8 to 12.