Reviewed by Kyle F. (age 8)
My favorite part in the story was when the Pumpkin Elf came. I like that part because the Pumpkin Elf messed up the classroom. I thought that was funny. I like the illustrations in this book because they always show when Freddy is making a face. They show when he is mad or happy. I like the Pumpkin Elf because he is from two different holidays, Halloween and Christmas. I also like how he always comes when you donít think he will come.
I recommend the Pumpkin Elf Mystery to kids in the third grade and second grade. I say that because it might be too hard for someone in first grade and too easy for fourth grade. If you like Halloween, you are going to like this book. I think boys and girls would like this book because both boys and girls like Halloween.