Reviewed by Caroline J (age 9)
I like when Andrew’s butt gets bigger because everyone laughs at him because his butt sticks out. I thought that was funny because when I read that I thought about “liar, liar pants on fire.” I also like the illustrations because the illustrator put in so much detail and they are funny. For example one illustration that is funny is when the illustrator drew Dr. Stufflebean because he added so much detail and it is really funny. It is really funny because the illustrator drew a cigar in Dr. Stufflebean’s mouth and he was leaning back in a chair. What I don’t like is that Andrew lies so much because I know that lying is wrong. Two things Andrew lies about are fooling around with the polygraph and wrestling with an alligator.
I recommend this book because it is very funny. Whoever likes funny stories will probably like this book. I think 7 to 12 year olds will like this book because anyone younger than 7 probably won’t understand this book. Anyone older than 12 will think it is dumb. For example, Andrew gets stuck in the bathroom stall. Kids older than 12 might think that is dumb.