Reviewed by Christopher L. (age 9)
When I read the book, I thought there was some really cool parts. I thought it was cool when Pops Warner got knocked out. That was neat because you don't see that in a children's book everyday! I also like how Noelle and Todd kept working on the case and never gave up. I think there is something very unique about this book. Mr. Merlin is always giving the detectives clues, and he lets them work on it during school. I would like to do that! While I was reading, I thought the mystery was never going to be solved. I thought that because it was probably one of the hardest mysteries I ever read. I'm glad I was able to figure it out in the end.
I would recommend the book to kids in grades 2nd-3rd because it's a hard mystery. Also it's a great mystery. I liked how the author never came out and told you who did the crime. If you're a person who likes hard crime mysteries this is the book for you!