Reviewed by Sean L. (age 8)
I like this book because it is vey unpredictable. You never know where Nate and Duncan are going to go next. I also think it was interesting how Sludge, Nate's dog, ended up helping to find the book. To me Nate is a good detective. He never stops until the case is solved.
I would recommend this book to strong first through third graders who like Nate the Great books. It is a just right book because there aren't a lot of tricky words. I liked it and I think you will, too!